Prototype testing is an important part of the product design and development process for top-class product teams committed to continuous improvement of their product. In today’s highly competitive market (both for B2C and B2B), prototype testing is a core part of any top-notch product team’s research strategy, ensuring that the final product is not only functional but also free from usability issues. By catching errors and potential pitfalls early, this process conserves time and energy, streamlining the entire development journey.
But why is prototype testing so crucial? Well, it helps teams identify design flaws before they become costly problems, validates that the product meets user needs and expectations, and significantly reduces the risk of expensive revisions later on. Additionally, it fosters a deeper understanding of how users interact with your product, offering insights that can be pivotal in refining and enhancing the user experience. This comprehensive ten-step guide will provide you with clear, actionable instructions on how to effectively test prototypes, equipping you with essential techniques to excel in your next prototype testing project.
What is Prototype Testing?
Prototype testing allows product teams to test an early version of a product to evaluate its functionality and ease of use, addressing potential issues related to layout, applicability, or design before the final model is produced. By identifying and rectifying these problems early on, prototype testing ensures the creation of a product that performs optimally and meets users' needs and demands to the fullest extent. This process not only enhances the product’s usability but also aligns it more closely with user expectations, ultimately delivering a superior end result.
Recruit quality B2C and B2B participants in less than 30 minutes with Hubble
Streamline your research by building studies and recruiting participants in a single tool
The Importance of Prototype Testing
Now that we know what prototype testing is let’s discuss the importance of testing prototypes
- Identifies Design Flaws Early - Prototyping allows for the creation of an early product model, enabling the discovery of design flaws before the final build. By identifying and addressing these shortcomings during the design process, costly revisions are eliminated, resulting in a smoother final product.
- Validates Functionality and Usability - Prototyping confirms that the product delivers the right value proposition and effectively solves end-user problems. It provides a means to gather valuable information on user navigation and interaction before actual use, ensuring the product meets user expectations.
- Reduces Development Costs - Addressing issues at the prototype stage is significantly more cost-effective than resolving them during later stages of development or production. By catching problems early, prototyping saves considerable time and money.
- Enhances Product Quality - Prototyping follows ideation, where multiple iterations ensure the final product is of excellent quality. This iterative process continuously refines the design and functionality, leading to a superior end result.
- Aids in Marketing and Development Proposals - Prototyping provides insights into how the product is expected to perform in the market. This information is invaluable for setting up marketing strategies, positioning, and further development, ensuring the final product meets customer expectations.
- Builds Stakeholder Confidence—Prototyping validates the market concept and builds confidence among stakeholders, including investors, partners, and potential customers. Demonstrating that the prototype has been tested and refined reassures stakeholders about the product's viability, helping to mobilize support and approval.
Understanding the Different Types of Prototypes
Now that we’ve covered what prototype testing is and why it’s crucial, let’s delve into the various types of prototypes and their specific use cases. Understanding these types will help you choose the most suitable prototype for your development stage and ensure that you’re making the most of each iteration.
Feasibility Prototypes
- Used for prototyping new technology or idea (ex. updated algorithm).
- Software engineer writes just enough code to see if it's feasible.
- Helps understand technical risk, often related to performance.
Low-Fidelity Prototypes
- Low-fidelity prototypes are essentially interactive wireframes (doesn't look real).
- Created by interactive designers to test the workflow.
- Simulates process to identify usability issues early.
High-Fidelity Prototypes
- Realistic looking, working simulation.
- Good for communicating a proposed product to stakeholders.
- Used in defensive user testing, not to see if they'll like it, but to learn if they won't.
Live Data Prototypes
- Working implementation with limited functinalities created by developers to actually prove it works.
- Connects to real data and its served through staging / testing link
- Has not yet been "productized" (no test automation, SEO, localization, etc).
Understanding these types of prototypes and their specific use cases will help you make informed decisions at each stage of your development process while ensuring that you gather valuable insights and make necessary improvements before the final release. Please see our article on optimizing Figma prototypes for testing.
Step 1: Define Your Objectives
Before diving into the testing phase, it’s crucial to set clear goals. Start by defining what you aim to achieve with your prototype testing. Are you looking to measure usability, functionality, or a combination of both? Identifying the purpose and objectives of your project will guide your prototype testing methods effectively. In order to help you in this process, Hubble offers various templates that you can select depending on your project’s needs.
Assess Usability
Determine if users can interact with the prototype as intended without confusion or errors. Usability testing focuses on evaluating the product’s interface to ensure it is user-friendly and intuitive.
Elevate your continuous UX Research
Validate your concepts and collect post-launch feedback through Hubble
Evaluate Functionality
Ensure that all designed features and functionalities work as expected. This testing verifies that the product interfaces perform correctly and achieve the intended tasks seamlessly.
Improve User Experience
Gather insights on the overall impressions users have of the prototype. This includes assessing user satisfaction, interactions, and emotional responses to the product.
Identify Bugs and Issues
Document any issues users encounter, such as bugs, glitches, or general inconveniences. Early identification of these problems allows for timely corrections before the final product release.
By defining these objectives, you’ll be better equipped to conduct thorough and effective prototype testing, ultimately leading to a more refined and successful product.
Step 2: Choose the Right User Research Tool
Before making a prototype, pick a tool that fits your research needs. If you need to test wireframes or prototypes with clickable designs, consider Hubble. It’s great for checking various design aspects. If you want to hear and see user reactions during tests, use Clips for detailed feedback.
Step 3: Choose the Right Prototype
Selecting the appropriate prototype type is essential for efficient and effective testing. Prototypes can vary based on the goals and objectives of your project. Early-stage dummies are useful for initial evaluations, while true replicas, with all features of the actual product, are more suitable for later stages. Therefore, choosing the right prototype for your testing phase is crucial.
Low-Fidelity Prototypes
- Sketches: Rough sketches of the product or graphical user interface.
- Wireframes: Schematic drawings that outline layout ideas and element placement without detailed decoration. Tools like Figma, Framer and Protopie offer various ways to build wireframes that can be useful.
- Paper Prototypes: Paper-based prototypes where interactions are acted out as if they are with the physical object.
High-Fidelity Prototypes
- Interactive Mockups: Design representations of the product with interactive areas where users can simulate interactions.
- Functional Models: Physical mock-up models that closely resemble the original design in look, feel, and complete functionality.
Deciding on the fidelity level of your prototype depends on the development phase and the nature of the feedback you seek. Early-stage exploration benefits from low-fidelity prototypes, as they allow for rapid adjustments during stakeholder testing. For detailed usability testing and refinement, high-fidelity prototypes are more appropriate.
By choosing the right prototype for each phase, you can maximize the efficiency and effectiveness of your testing process, ensuring valuable insights and a polished final product.
Step 4: Recruit the Right Participants
To gather valuable insights through prototype testing, it’s essential to recruit the right testers that will give you helpful insights. This involves considering user demographics, behavior patterns, and familiarity with the product. Pre-screening participants ensure that those involved in the study provide meaningful feedback for product improvement.
- Identify Target Audience
- Demographics: Consider age, gender, geographical location, and other relevant characteristics for your specific product.
- User Behavior: Examine aspects of users’ daily lives that align with your product’s features and primary purpose.
- Experience Level: Evaluate previous experience with similar or competing products that may influence their interaction with your prototype.
- Recruitment Strategies
- User Research Panels: Utilize panels or pre-filled databases to target actual users for your tests.
- Social Media and Online Communities: Advertise on social media platforms and discussion groups frequented by your target audience.
- Incentives: Offer incentives such as gift cards, discounts, or exclusive access to encourage participation.
Step 5: Select the Appropriate Testing Methods
Choosing the right testing methods depends on your prototype’s objectives and type. Here are some common methods:
Usability Testing
Implement specific usage scenarios to analyze user interactions with the prototype and identify potential issues. By observing users' interactions, you can pinpoint areas where they struggle or become confused. This testing method also helps you assess whether the prototype is intuitive and user-friendly and whether it effectively meets the needs of its intended audience. Checkout our guide on writing usability test plans, if you need additional resources to create usability testing plans.
A/B Testing
Compare different versions of the prototype to determine which one performs better. For more details, check out our blog on ‘How to Overcome the Limitations of A/B Testing.’
Surveys and Interviews
Gather qualitative data on user opinions and experiences to gain deeper insights.
Selecting the appropriate testing methods ensures you obtain the most relevant feedback. Using a combination of methods provides a comprehensive analysis of your prototype’s strengths and challenges, leading to a well-rounded understanding of its performance and areas for improvement.
By following these steps, you can ensure your prototype testing process is thorough, effective, and aligned with your product development goals.
Collect contextual feedback from users real-time
Set up in-product surveys in a few clicks with Hubble
Step 6: Prepare Testing Materials
As you gear up for prototype testing, thorough preparation is key. Gather all necessary materials, including the actual prototypes, test scripts, questionnaires, and recording tools. By having plans, designs, scenarios, and promotional materials ready in advance, you’ll streamline the testing phase and focus on observing user behavior.
Prototype
Ensure your prototype is fully functional and accurately reflects the usability and functionality issues you wish to evaluate. Verify that interactive elements, such as buttons and illustrations, are operational and aligned with your testing goals.
Test Scripts
Develop detailed test scripts outlining participant tasks. Each task should include clear instructions, potential scenarios, and the overall objective. Comprehensive scripts will guide users effectively and ensure consistent testing conditions. Please see this article for help on writing effective usability testing scripts.
Questionnaires
Prepare pre-test and post-test surveys to gather essential participant information, such as age, gender, occupation, education level, and prior experience with similar applications. Include both closed and open-ended questions to capture a broad spectrum of feedback, providing valuable insights for prototype development.
- Recording Equipment
Set up screen or video-capturing tools to document user activity. Ensure audio clarity when recording any participant comments or feedback. This will help you review interactions and identify areas for improvement. - Consent Forms
Draft consent forms to obtain participants’ permission for recording their responses and using them in the study. This is crucial for maintaining ethical standards and ensuring transparency in your testing process.
Step 7: Conduct a Pilot Test
Conducting a pilot test is crucial for identifying potential issues before the main testing phase. It allows you to refine your approach and ensure your prototype testing is as effective as possible.
Select Pilot Participants
Choose a group of participants from your target market for the pilot test. Aim to select individuals who closely match the characteristics and behaviors of your main test group to ensure relevant feedback. Please see this guide on recruiting research participants.
Run the Pilot Test
Execute the pilot test under the same conditions as the main test. Observe and document any challenges or issues encountered by participants. This will provide insights into potential improvements needed for the main testing phase.
Identify Issues
Review feedback and recordings from the pilot test to pinpoint problems related to the prototype, test scripts, or testing environment. Look for areas needing clarification, refinement, or adjustment.
Make Adjustments
Based on pilot test results, revise the prototype, test scripts, and materials as needed. Address all identified issues to ensure the main testing sessions run smoothly and yield meaningful results. With meticulous preparation and a thorough pilot test, you’ll be well-equipped to conduct effective prototype testing, leading to a refined and successful final product.
Step 8: Run the Tests
When it’s time to put your prototype to the test, your role is to carefully observe and document how users interact with your creation. Pay attention to their actions, facial expressions, and verbal feedback. This is your chance to collect comprehensive data to refine your prototype for the next iteration.
Facilitate the Test
Guide participants through the testing session with clear instructions and be prepared to answer any questions they might have. Encourage them to articulate their thoughts and feelings as they interact with the prototype. This verbal feedback will be invaluable for understanding their experience.
Observe Interactions
Keep a close eye on how users engage with the prototype, noting any difficulties, misunderstandings, or errors they encounter. Watch for both verbal and non-verbal cues, such as frustration, satisfaction, or confusion, as these can provide deeper insights into their experience.
Gather Feedback
Collect qualitative data through interviews or short post-test questionnaires that focus on participants' impressions, preferences, and concerns. Use standardized questionnaires to gather quantitative data on task completion rates, perceived satisfaction, and overall usability.
Document Findings
Take detailed notes on the key observations and feedback received. Ensure that all recordings and notes are properly archived for future reference. This documentation will be crucial for the iterative improvement of your prototype.
Step 9: Iterate Based on Feedback
Once you’ve analyzed the results, it’s time to implement changes. Use the insights gained from prototype testing to refine and enhance your product. This iterative process is essential for developing a product that truly meets user expectations.
Implement Changes
Address the high-priority issues identified during the testing phase. Focus on resolving design, functionality, or usability problems based on user feedback. Implement these changes to improve the overall product experience.
Prototype Refinement
Update your prototype to reflect the changes made. Ensure that all modifications are thoroughly tested to validate their effectiveness. This step is crucial for ensuring that the improvements made are successful and align with user needs.
Continuous Improvement
Adopt an incremental approach to prototype refinement. Continue to gather user feedback and incorporate new ideas as they arise. Stay flexible and open to adjustments throughout the development process.
Step 10: Repeat the Process
Prototype testing is an ongoing, iterative process rather than a one-time event. Multiple rounds of testing are necessary to optimize your product through successive iterations. Each testing phase provides new insights and opportunities for improvement.
Plan Subsequent Tests
Organize additional testing sessions to evaluate the changes made and identify any remaining issues. Adjust your testing objectives and methods based on the current state of the prototype.
Gather Diverse Feedback
Involve a varied group of participants in subsequent tests to gain a comprehensive understanding of different user perspectives. Comparing feedback from diverse user types and scenarios will help you build a more robust product.
Track Progress
Monitor and document the changes made during each iteration, noting their impact on the prototype. Keep track of the outcomes and improvements resulting from each round of testing to ensure continued progress and refinement.
By systematically running tests, iterating based on feedback, and repeating the process, you'll continuously enhance your prototype, bringing it closer to a successful final product.
Integrating Prototype Testing with Other Testing Methods
Integrating various testing methods ensures a comprehensive evaluation of your product’s performance, extending beyond the scope of prototype testing alone. Here’s how to combine different approaches for optimal results:
- Unmoderated Testing
Unmoderated testing allows participants to interact with the prototype in their natural environment without the presence of a moderator. This method provides valuable insights into how users engage with the product and uncovers potential issues that might not surface in a controlled setting. It’s a great way to assess genuine user reactions and identify usability problems that might be overlooked during more structured tests. - Comprehensive Evaluation
By running unmoderated prototype tests, you gain both controlled results and real-world insights into your product’s performance. This dual approach helps in addressing a wider range of issues, ensuring that the final product not only meets design specifications but also performs well in everyday use. This comprehensive evaluation enhances the quality of the final product, making it more likely to succeed in the market.
For further insights on unmoderated testing benefits, check out our blog on the Benefits of Unmoderated Testing.
Conclusion
Prototype testing is a powerful tool that can be used during product development, aimed at helping develop high quality products for users. By adhering to this guide—from defining objectives and selecting prototypes to analyzing results and iterating—you can ensure that your product evolves effectively throughout its development stages. Using unmoderated testing to run prototype tests enriches the development process, providing a more comprehensive view of your product’s functionality. Remember, prototype testing is an iterative process involving continuous refinement and feedback to achieve a product that surpasses user expectations. With these prototype testing steps, you will be able to test more quickly and effectively, building products that are more
Frequently Asked Questions
There are several techniques for testing prototypes, such as:
- Paper sketch testing
- Card sorting
- A/B testing
- Usability testing
- Wireframe testing
- Surveys
The four steps for testing a prototype are as follows:
- Develop quantifiable and transparent test objectives.
- Make a prototype in high-, low-, or mi-fidelity.
- Use actual users to administer the exam.
- Obtain feedback and make necessary modifications.
Prototyping is carried out because it aids in the early detection of design defects and inefficiencies by product teams. Teams are able to produce better and more successful products when they test early on with actual users. Prototype testing, however, can take place at any point in the product's lifecycle. It is indeed possible to create goods that your people would adore by regularly testing and validating new features both before and after they are launched.
Prototype models come in two or three variations:
Low to medium fidelity: A basic and less expensive version of the item. It might be a cardboard 3D model, a handcrafted sketch, or a wireframe. Or an almost-finished version that has been marginally enhanced. Enables you to create anticipated flows and pathways and validate concepts.
High fidelity, or hi-fi: It refers to a costly, more detailed, and longer-to-produce version of the product that is extremely comparable to the final form. It enables you to evaluate the usability
.png)
